I'm feeling a little bit heartbroken as I write this post, as I've had to replace my Stila Stay All Day Liner, which I absolutely ADORED. I'm always a bit wary with felt-tip liners because I've had issues with them coming out really faded or just smudging everywhere, which sucks as I definitely find them easiest to use, but the Stila liner is just amazing. As I'm on a bit of a budget this month, what with Christmas to think about, I did a sensible and decided not to spend £15 on an eyeliner and look for a cheaper one instead. This one was fairly high up on the Boots Top Rated list when I checked their website and at £6.99, I figured it was worth a try!
First Impressions
So the first thing I noticed with this liner is that the nib is a LOT thicker than the Stila one, which I'm not sure about as I like to have a slightly thinner line if I can help it. That being said, when I swatched it I had a bit of an experiment and the actual tip is still quite thin, so you can alternate between which kind of line you want. The thicker part will probably be better for filling in my wings and at least I know I can still get a thin, precise line if I want to. The pigment is also really good; I was worried it would come out more grey than black but I'm pretty happy with the colour.
How It Looked
Ok so I have mixed feelings with this liner having used it for a couple of days. This liner is very temperamental; the first few times I wore it I was pretty pissed off because it had leaked into the creases of my eyelids by the end of the day, something I've found to be a problem with felt-tip liners. HOWEVER it then managed to survive a very sweaty Legs, Bums and Tums class I did at the gym. It had faded a tiny bit but it still looked pretty good considering how hot I got during that class. I'm thinking the trick is to always wear eyelid primer (I'm using the NYX Proof It! Primer at the moment). It was really easy to use and the initial pigment was really nice too, so it's not all bad. I still definitely prefer the Stila one, but for a fraction of the price this liner ain't so bad.
Rating - 3/5
Rating - 3/5
Comments
Post a Comment